Don't use iCloud for photo backup

Delete a photo from iPhone, iCloud kills it too

My friend Bill just returned from a family vacation in Costa Rica and shot lots of photos and video on his iPhone, including some killer shots of breakfasts with local monkeys.

No surprise that once he got home, he checked his iPhone storage and found that it was 98% full. Just a few more snaps, and he’d be totally out of room.

His solution? “I’ll just put them all on iCloud, and then delete them off my iPhone,” he told me.

NO, NO, NO!

That’s the worst thing he could do. Because once they’re uploaded to iCloud, the next time it scans his phone for an automatic backup, it will notice that the Costa Rica pix are gone and in turn delete them from the cloud backup as well.

Ever notice the fine print when you try to delete a photo? “This item will be deleted from iCloud Photos on all your devices.”

For pure photo backup, because of these weird, arcane rules, Apple’s iCloud is about the worst place to go. Apple’s help support reps told me over several calls that iCloud is meant for backup of your devices, not just your photo library, and as a way to have the same data available on all your Apple devices, not just the iPhone.

As Apple puts it: “Automatically upload and safely store all your photos and videos in iCloud so you can browse, search and share from any of your devices.” Notice the word backup doesn’t appear there anywhere?

How Apple wants the process to work:

Remember the old Apple ad asking us to “Think Different?” It’s the same thing when it comes to backup. Apple just does it differently. In Apple’s world, you don’t delete images off the phone, you just convert them to low-resolution copies, and download the high-resolution originals from iCloud.

You can make the switch from high to low by clicking “optimize” in the Settings section, under your name at the top of the screen.

We’re all taking more photos and videos than ever before, in higher resolution, and the fact is, we outgrow our phone’s storage all the time. All of us needs to pay more attention to backup strategies. Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Dropbox and SmugMug have different plans (they all charge) that don’t involve deleting your cloud photos if you’ve gotten rid of them from your phone.

There is no free storage available anywhere for more than a handful of photos and videos. And no, Facebook and Instagram don’t count, as images are ground down to super low-resolution and you’ll never get the full res version back.

(Note: SmugMug is sponsoring the upcoming fourth season of my #PhotowalksTV streaming series.)

What Bill should do:

If he insists on sticking with iCloud, there is a workaround, but it will take more work.

Obviously, first he could convert all his iPhone photos to low-resolution, upload them and leave the copies on his phone.

Option 2, the workaround way.

Upload the images to iCloud. And double the effort by backing up the same images somewhere else as well. The easiest is a small portable hard drive. A LaCie Rugged drive with 4 terabytes of storage costs around $150, or about $50 more than 1 year of 2 TB service from Apple.

Now that we’re backed up twice, confirm that all the Costa Rica images are there. Then in the iCloud settings, TURN OFF iCloud backup.

This way, iCloud won’t be able to do a sweep of the phone and mirror what it sees—i.e., no Costa Rica pix.

After Bill takes a bunch more new images on his phone, he can manually put them into iCloud by putting iCloud Backup on again.

This isn’t the proper or ideal way to back up photos, however. Nor is it a long-term solution: Apple will actually delete your files from its cloud 180 days after you turn off iCloud backup, so be aware of that.

The Safer Way

Dropbox and Microsoft charge $9.99 monthly for 1 TB of storage, Google $9.99 for 2 TB of storage and SmugMug starts at $9 monthly with unlimited storage. Amazon also offers unlimited photo (but not video) backup at no charge to subscribers of the $139 yearly Amazon Prime shipping and entertainment service. Pure, no-gimmicks online photo backup + at least one hard drive on the desk makes me feel more comfortable. Better would be one drive on the desk, one drive offsite and online backup.

And in case you’re wondering, I have 8 drives on my desk, several more in the closet and I subscribe to SmugMug, Google One and Amazon.

In other news

Apple, as you know, had its big product reveal this week, and the spotlight was on that ultra-pricey new Mac Studio computer, which fully loaded tops $10,000, or the budget iPhone, a new and improved SE, for $429.

Many people have asked me about the SE, and whether it was a worthwhile buy. The good: more powerful A15 processing chip, the same as in the iPhone 13, which means faster operation and better computational photography. The SE comes with just 1 camera lens, compared to 3 on the top of the line 13 Pro Max, an ultra-wide, wide and portrait lens.

Sure, having three lenses is cool, but most of us started out in photography with one prime lens, and we made it work. If we wanted to zoom in closer, we used our feet. And with the SE, if you needed an ultra-wide shot, you have a workaround. Just shoot in panorama mode and you’ve got it.

I’d rather have the expensive model, but as a new phone for the kids, I wouldn’t think twice. The SE is a great deal.

Substack app

Our friends at Substack, which hosts this newsletter, released an app this week. The idea is that for all of you who find my work hidden in the “promotions” section of Gmail, you have an alternative. You can get notifications about new posts in the app, and use it to catch up on other Substack writers as well.

Per Substack: “With the app, you’ll have a dedicated Inbox for my Substack and any others you subscribe to. New posts will never get lost in your email filters, or stuck in spam. Longer posts will never cut-off by your email app. Comments and rich media will all work seamlessly. Overall, it’s a big upgrade to the reading experience.

The Substack app is currently available for iOS. If you don’t have an Apple device, you can join the Android waitlist here.

Last week I told you about a death in the family. You know what people do after funerals? Hit the bagels!

This week’s #iPhonePhotoShow podcast features an interview with ace concert photographer Steve Brazill, and we announce the winners of the February photo contest.

Thanks as always for reading, watching and listening. Have questions about online photo backup? I’d love to chat with you. Just click reply, or look for me on Twitter or Facebook.

Jeff